Search

Employment Law News

Paying older workers larger redundancy payments is discriminatory but justified

In order to establish discrimination, a Claimant must establish that they have been treated differently to a comparator whose circumstances are materially the same to their own (with the only difference being a protected characteristic such as age, race, disability etc). In Lockwood v. DWP, an age discrimination case, the Court of Appeal gave short shrift to the suggestion that there was a material difference between groups of workers (and therefore no comparator) on the basis of circumstances intrinsically linked to age.

Read More »

Christian wins case against employer over gay marriage remarks

“In Smith v Trafford Housing Trust, Mr Smith posted a link on his Facebook wall to a BBC news article entitled “Gay church marriages set to get the go-ahead” and commented that it was “an equality too far”. In response, his colleague posted a comment on his wall, “Does this mean you don’t approve?”. Mr Smith replied “no, not really, I don’t understand why people who have no faith and don’t believe in Christ would want to get hitched in church. The bible is quite specific that marriage is for men and women. If the state wants to offer civil marriage to same sex then that is up to the state; but the state shouldn’t impose its rules on places of faith and conscience”.

Read More »

Can you be fairly dismissed for theft when you have been acquitted in a criminal trial?

Yes, according to the Court of Appeal in Stuart v London City Airport. Mr Stuart worked at London City Airport until he was dismissed for attempting to steal goods from a duty free shop. He brought an unfair dismissal claim arguing that LCA had not carried out an adequate investigation, in particular that they had not reviewed the CCTV footage in response to the duty free shop manager’s accusation that he was concealing items under his coat.

Read More »

Are interns at commercial companies entitled to the minimum wage?

At the other end of the pay spectrum, Chris Jarvis, an intern at Sony, successfully negotiated a £4,600 settlement for unpaid wages during his three month internship. Mr Jarvis said that instead of shadowing a Sony employee, he was working as a tester for the games department and therefore was entitled to minimum wage.. Sony unsuccessfully asked Mr Jarvis to sign a gagging order.

Read More »

Do mothers who have children through surrogates have a right to maternity leave?

The European Court of Justice has been asked to decide a mothers’ right to maternity leave if she has a baby through a surrogacy arrangement. Two cases have been referred to the ECJ and the Advocate Generals (advisers for the ECJ) have offered conflicting opinions. Such opinions are usually adopted as final judgments by the ECJ but in this scenario only one can be.

Read More »

Tribunal finds unfair dismissal even though employee admits to gross misconduct

Mr Benali worked as a chef at a Kosher bakery. In 2007-08, he was absent from work for a year as a result of his disability. On his return to work, a dispute arose with his employers over reasonable adjustments to his duties and he issued disability discrimination proceedings which were later settled. However, the requests for adjustments continued and his employers’ attitude toward him ‘hardened’.

Read More »